Ratified on a Promise1 / 10

Part One · The Price of Ratification

On February 6, 1788, Massachusetts ratified the Constitution by 187 votes to 168, and it did so on a condition. Federalists, the plan's supporters, had agreed to recommend a list of amendments amounting to a bill of rights. Six of the states that voted afterward attached similar recommendations, so the promise did not belong to the state of Massachusetts alone. Alexander Hamilton figured that most New Yorkers opposed the Constitution, and one historian of the convention judges it probable that most Americans did. Only the promise of amendments, that account concludes, ensured a Federalist victory. Ratification and amendment were bargained together, which is an unusual way to begin a rulebook: by promising to change it.

More to do at Peabody

About Ratified on a Promise

A free High school story from the Peabody library, Level 14. It has 10 short pages and about 1239 words, so it reads in a few minutes.

Words this story teaches

At reading level 14, Peabody's practice works on vocabulary, spelling; the level page says what is in each.

To print it or save it as a PDF, tap the ⓘ button above the story, then “Print this story”.

All the Level 14 stories, or the whole library.

For teachers: read it to the class, questions and key
Questions and answer key (6)
  1. What promise helped Massachusetts ratify the Constitution in 1788?
    • A. Lower taxes
    • B. A list of amendments amounting to a bill of rights
    • C. A new capital
    Show answerB. A list of amendments amounting to a bill of rights
  2. Why were the ten ratified amendments numbered 1 to 10 when they had been Articles 3 to 12?
    • A. They were renumbered for fun
    • B. They were written first
    • C. The first two of the twelve were left behind, so the rest moved up
    Show answerC. The first two of the twelve were left behind, so the rest moved up
  3. According to Article V, how many states must ratify an amendment?
    • A. Three fourths
    • B. Two thirds
    • C. All of them
    Show answerA. Three fourths
  4. In this book, what does superfluous mean?
    • A. Dangerous
    • B. Not needed
    • C. Secret
    Show answerB. Not needed
  5. How can an amendment be repealed?
    • A. By a court
    • B. By adding another amendment
    • C. By a vote of Congress alone
    Show answerB. By adding another amendment
  6. Why did Marbury v. Madison matter beyond who got the job?
    • A. It showed the Court could void a law that conflicts with the Constitution, a power the text does not name
    • B. It ended the Civil War
    • C. It added a new amendment
    Show answerA. It showed the Court could void a law that conflicts with the Constitution, a power the text does not name

For grown-ups: Peabody has no ads, not one, and nothing to sell your child. The Kids Pick, an independent kids' directory, rates its games 90/100. See what other free kids' sites load · Already have a profile?