Music, level 13
🎻 Overtones and Timbre
Why does a flute sound different from a violin even when both play exactly the same note?
- Why does a flute sound different from a violin even when both play exactly the same note? The explanation begins with a surprising fact: a single musical note is almost never made of just one frequency. When a string vibrates along its whole length, it produces the fundamental, the lowest and usually the strongest frequency, which listeners recognize as the pitch of the note. At the same time, however, the string is also vibrating in smaller sections, in halves, thirds, quarters and even smaller pieces, and each of these extra motions adds a higher tone called an overtone. For an ideal string, these overtones form what is known as the harmonic series, a set of frequencies that are exact whole-number multiples of the fundamental. A string with a fundamental of 110 hertz, for example, also gives off harmonics at about 220, 330 and 440 hertz, all of them sounding together at once, even though you hear only a single note.
- These harmonics line up neatly with familiar musical intervals. The second harmonic, which vibrates twice as fast as the fundamental, sounds one octave higher, because a ratio of two to one is exactly what defines the octave. The third harmonic, at three times the fundamental, sounds an octave and a perfect fifth above it, and the fourth harmonic sounds two full octaves above it. Under ordinary conditions, a listener hears the fundamental clearly while the overtones blend into it without being noticed, although with practice and careful attention the overtones themselves can sometimes be picked out one by one. Not every instrument follows this tidy pattern, however. Bars of metal or wood, like the bars of a marimba, along with cymbals, chimes and drums, produce what are called nonharmonic overtones, whose frequencies are not whole-number multiples of the lowest one, so their overtones do not line up neatly with the harmonic series.
- The particular blend of overtones explains timbre, which is the characteristic tone color of an instrument or a voice. A sound's timbre depends on its wave form, and the wave form depends on how many overtones are present, what their frequencies are and how strong each one is compared with the others. A tuning fork, for instance, makes a clear, pure tone because its sound contains almost no overtones at all. A clarinet's woody sound comes from its emphasis on low odd-numbered harmonics, whereas an oboe sounds more nasal because it contains all of the harmonics, with extra strength in the higher ones. So when a flute and a violin both play the A at 440 hertz, they share the very same fundamental, yet each one mixes its own recipe of overtones on top of it, and your ear hears those two recipes as two voices that you could never mistake for each other.
Try it at home: Play the same note on two different instruments or apps, or sing it with two different vowels, like ee and oo. Talk about how the pitch stays the same while the tone color changes.
Questions and answers
Overtones and Timbre
- What is the fundamental of a vibrating string? The lowest frequency, heard as the pitch (The whole string vibrating gives the fundamental, which we hear as the note's pitch.)
- Where do a string's overtones come from? The string vibrating in sections (Halves, thirds and quarters of the string vibrate too, adding higher tones.)
- What makes a set of overtones a harmonic series? They are exact multiples of the fundamental (Harmonic frequencies are whole-number multiples, such as two, three and four times the fundamental.)
- A string's fundamental is 110 hertz. Which of these is one of its harmonics? 330 hertz (330 is 3 times 110, so it is the third harmonic.)
- How far above the fundamental does the second harmonic sound? One octave (A two-to-one ratio is the octave.)
- How far above the fundamental does the third harmonic sound? An octave and a perfect fifth (At three times the fundamental, the third harmonic lands an octave and a fifth higher.)