Skip to the main content
PeabodyMake a free story

🔒 Online, level 12

What the trails say and what they ask. Print it for the class, or put the same questions on the board with a live quiz.

Online, level 12

↔️ Reading Laterally

How can you tell whether a website you have never heard of is trustworthy?

  • How can you tell whether a website you have never heard of is trustworthy? Many people try to answer by studying the page itself, checking whether it looks professional, displays an impressive logo or uses an address that sounds official. Teachers call that habit vertical reading, because you stay on one page and scroll up and down it. The difficulty is that almost anyone can build a polished, convincing website. Researchers at the Stanford History Education Group, whose work Common Sense Education draws on, watched professional fact-checkers evaluate unfamiliar sites and noticed a different habit: the fact-checkers quickly left the page to find out what other sources said about it. This strategy is called lateral reading, since you move sideways across many sources instead of digging deeper into a single one. You learn about a page by leaving it.
  • Common Sense Education defines lateral reading as a way to check the credibility of online information by leaving the source and seeing what other sources say about the claim and about who made it. Credibility means how believable and trustworthy a source is. In practice, you open a new browser tab and search for the name of the organization or the author, sometimes adding words such as funding or who runs it. Then you look at what independent sources, such as established news organizations, encyclopedias and libraries, report about who is behind the site, who pays for it and what it is ultimately trying to accomplish. Then you compare what you find. A site might describe itself as a neutral research group, for example, while other sources reveal that it is operated by a company that sells the very product the site keeps praising.
  • Lateral reading also means checking the claim itself, not only the source. Corroboration is support for a claim from additional sources, so if a surprising fact appears on just one website and nowhere else, that is a warning sign worth taking seriously. The Library of Congress encourages students to ask how the factual information in a source can be corroborated, and what additional perspectives are needed before reaching a conclusion. None of this requires you to decide within a few seconds whether a site is good or bad. It simply asks you to gather evidence patiently from several independent directions, the way professional fact-checkers do, before you believe something, share it with friends or use it in your own schoolwork. With practice, a quick lateral check can take less than a minute and can save you from accidentally spreading something false to the people who trust you.

Try it at home: Pick an unfamiliar website together, open a new tab and search its name, and talk about what other sources say about who runs it.

Questions and answers

Reading Laterally

  1. Staying on one page and judging it by how it looks is called… vertical reading (Vertical reading means staying on one page and scrolling up and down it.)
  2. 🎨 Why is a professional look a weak sign that a website is trustworthy? Almost anyone can build a polished site (Looks are easy to copy, so they say little about who is behind a site.)
  3. What did researchers notice professional fact-checkers doing with unfamiliar sites? Leaving the page to see what others said (The fact-checkers quickly left an unfamiliar page to see what other sources said about it.)
  4. ↔️ How does Common Sense Education define lateral reading? Checking credibility by leaving the source (You leave the source to see what other sources say about the claim and its author.)
  5. What does credibility mean? How believable and trustworthy a source is
  6. 🔎 In lateral reading, what do you search for in a new tab? The organization's or author's name