Science, level 13
🌡️ Heat, Energy and Entropy
Why can't anyone build a machine that runs forever?
- Why can't anyone build a machine that runs forever? For centuries, inventors sketched elaborate wheels, pumps and swinging arms designed to keep moving without any fuel at all, and every one of them eventually came to a stop. The explanation lies in thermodynamics, the branch of physics that studies heat, work and energy and the ways in which they are connected to one another. Its first law is a statement of the conservation of energy: energy can be transformed from one form into another, but it is never created or destroyed. When a car burns gasoline, the chemical energy stored in the fuel becomes the energy of motion, together with a considerable amount of heat, and when a bicycle brakes to a stop, its energy of motion becomes heat in the brake pads and the wheel rims. Throughout every such change, the total amount of energy remains exactly the same, so a machine that produced more energy than it received would be violating the first law.
- The first law, however, does not tell the whole story. Imagine a mug of hot cocoa sitting on a table in a cool room. The cocoa gradually cools while the surrounding air warms very slightly, until both of them reach the same temperature, and then the change stops. Energy would still be conserved if heat flowed the other way, making the cocoa hotter and the room colder, yet that never happens spontaneously, which means on its own, without help. The second law of thermodynamics describes this everyday observation: heat flows naturally from a hotter object to a colder one, and never in the reverse direction unless something forces it to. A refrigerator does move heat out of its cold interior and into the warmer kitchen, but it can do so only because a motor performs work to push the heat along, using electrical energy from the outlet in the wall. Without that outside work, the heat would simply leak back inside again.
- Physicists express the second law using a quantity called entropy, which, roughly speaking, measures how spread out, or dispersed, the energy within a system has become. Concentrated energy, such as the heat in the cocoa, is useful, because it can be made to do work as it flows from hot to cold. Once that energy has spread evenly throughout the room, it still exists, but it can no longer accomplish much of anything. The second law states that the total entropy of an isolated system, meaning one that exchanges neither energy nor matter with its surroundings, tends to increase over time. Every real machine experiences friction, the rubbing of one surface against another, so some of its energy is continually converted into dispersed heat that cannot be recovered. That is why a perpetual motion machine is impossible: even a superbly built wheel would gradually lose its useful energy to friction and finally come to rest.
Try it at home: Set a cup of hot water and a cup of cold water side by side, and check them every few minutes together to see both drift toward room temperature.
🧭 Earth's Magnetic Field
Why does a compass needle point north?
- Why does a compass needle point north? A compass needle is a small magnet that is free to turn, and it aligns itself with the far larger magnetic field that surrounds our entire planet. That field does not come from a gigantic bar magnet buried underground. Earth's core has two parts: a solid inner core and, wrapped around it, a liquid outer core made mostly of molten iron. Heat escaping from deep inside the planet keeps this molten metal slowly churning, rising in some places and sinking in others, while the turning of the Earth helps to organize the flow. Iron conducts electricity even when it is melted, and, as Oersted discovered long ago, electric charges that are moving create magnetic fields. This self-sustaining process, which continually regenerates the planet's field, is known as the geodynamo, a name that compares the core of the Earth to a giant electrical generator that never needs to be switched on.
- Earth's magnetic field reaches far out into space, where it forms a huge protective region called the magnetosphere. That protection matters because the Sun is continuously releasing a stream of electrically charged particles known as the solar wind. The magnetosphere turns most of these particles aside so that they flow around our planet, which helps to keep the solar wind from slowly wearing away the atmosphere, and it also turns aside much of the particle radiation thrown out by great eruptions on the Sun. Some charged particles, however, pick up energy inside the magnetosphere and are guided along the field toward two oval-shaped regions around the magnetic poles. There they collide with oxygen and nitrogen high in the atmosphere, and the excited gases release their extra energy as light, producing an aurora, the shimmering curtains of color in the night sky that people in the far north call the northern lights.
- Earth's magnetic field is not fixed; it changes continually, because the flow within the outer core keeps shifting. The north magnetic pole, which is where a compass actually points, is not the same place as the geographic North Pole. Since explorers first located it precisely in 1831, the north magnetic pole has drifted more than 600 miles, so the charts and systems that people use for finding their way must be updated regularly to stay accurate. Over much longer spans of time, the field has even reversed, meaning that magnetic north and magnetic south have exchanged places, and scientists know this because certain rocks preserve the direction of the field at the time they formed, much like a compass frozen in stone. According to NASA, these records show that reversals have happened many times, the most recent one about 780,000 years ago, and that each reversal unfolds gradually, over hundreds to thousands of years.
Try it at home: Take a compass outside together and see which way it points, then look up online how far your town's magnetic north is from true north.
Questions and answers
Heat, Energy and Entropy
- What does the first law of thermodynamics say about energy? It is never created or destroyed (The first law is the conservation of energy: energy only changes form.)
- 🚲 When a bicycle brakes to a stop, where does its energy of motion go? It becomes heat in the brakes and rims (The energy is not lost; it changes into heat.)
- Which way does heat flow on its own? From hotter to colder (The second law says heat flows naturally from a hotter object to a colder one.)
- How can a refrigerator move heat out of its cold inside? A motor does work, using electrical energy (Heat moves from cold to hot only when outside work pushes it.)
- 🌀 Roughly speaking, what does entropy measure? How spread out its energy is (Entropy roughly measures how dispersed the energy in a system has become.)
- What tends to happen to the total entropy of an isolated system over time? It increases (The second law says the entropy of an isolated system tends to rise.)
Earth's Magnetic Field
- What is a compass needle? A small magnet free to turn (The needle is a magnet that lines up with Earth's magnetic field.)
- 🌍 What is Earth's outer core mostly made of? Molten iron (The outer core is liquid, made mostly of molten iron.)
- What is the geodynamo? The process in the core that keeps making the field (Moving molten iron carries electric charges, which keep regenerating the field.)
- What is the magnetosphere? The protective region of Earth's magnetic field in space (The field reaches far into space and forms the magnetosphere.)
- ☀️ What is the solar wind? A stream of charged particles from the Sun (The Sun continuously releases charged particles called the solar wind.)
- How does the magnetosphere help Earth's atmosphere? It deflects the solar wind that could erode it (By turning the solar wind aside, the field helps keep the atmosphere from being worn away.)