Think, level 10
🔀 If, Then: Conditional Logic
If a statement is true, is it still true when you flip it around?
- If a statement is true, is it still true when you flip it around? Logic, the study of correct reasoning, gives a careful answer to that question. A conditional statement has the form if p, then q, where the first part, p, is called the hypothesis and the second part, q, is called the conclusion. Consider the true statement, if an animal is a dog, then it is a mammal, in which p is the animal is a dog and q is the animal is a mammal. A conditional makes only one promise, namely that whenever p is true, q must be true as well. It says nothing at all about what happens when p is false, so it is not contradicted by a cat, which is a mammal but not a dog. The only way to demonstrate that a conditional is false is to discover a single case in which p is true and q is false.
- There are three ways to rearrange a conditional statement. The converse exchanges the two parts, giving if an animal is a mammal, then it is a dog, and that statement is false, because a cat is a mammal that is not a dog. The inverse adds the word not to both parts without exchanging them, giving if an animal is not a dog, then it is not a mammal, and that statement is also false, as the very same cat demonstrates. So even when a conditional is true, its converse and its inverse may be false. Mathematicians watch carefully for this, which is why a theorem and its converse usually require separate proofs. Confusing a statement with its converse is a very common error in everyday reasoning, and it can lead people toward conclusions that the evidence simply does not support.
- The third rearrangement, called the contrapositive, both exchanges the parts and adds not to each one, giving if an animal is not a mammal, then it is not a dog. This statement is true, and it will always agree with the original. A conditional and its contrapositive are logically equivalent, which means that in every possible case they are either both true or both false. Here is the reason: if every dog is a mammal, then anything that fails to be a mammal cannot possibly be a dog. The same reasoning works for any conditional whatsoever. Suppose we know that whenever it rains, the sidewalk gets wet. The contrapositive tells us that if the sidewalk is dry, then it is not raining. Detectives, programmers and mathematicians use contrapositives constantly to reason backward from what they observe to what must be true.
Try it at home: Make up an if-then rule about your home, like if it is a school day then the alarm rings, and say its converse and contrapositive together.
Questions and answers
If, Then: Conditional Logic
- In the statement if p, then q, what is p called? The hypothesis (In if p, then q, p is the hypothesis and q is the conclusion.)
- How can you show that a conditional statement is false? Find a case where p is true and q is false (That is the only kind of case that breaks the promise of a conditional.)
- 🔁 What does the converse of if p, then q do? Swaps the two parts (The converse is if q, then p.)
- What is the inverse of if an animal is a dog, then it is a mammal? If it is not a dog, then it is not a mammal (The inverse adds not to both parts without swapping them.)
- Which rearrangement always has the same truth as the original statement? The contrapositive (A conditional and its contrapositive are logically equivalent.)
- What is the contrapositive of if p, then q? If not q, then not p (The contrapositive both swaps the parts and adds not to each.)