Skip to the main content
PeabodyMake a free story

🧩 Think, level 12

What the trails say and what they ask. Print it for the class, or put the same questions on the board with a live quiz.

Think, level 12

🔬 Testing an Idea

What makes an idea scientific?

  • What makes an idea scientific? A useful starting point is the hypothesis, a proposed explanation that can be checked against evidence. A good hypothesis makes a definite prediction, so that some possible observation could come out against it. Suppose Lena thinks her tomato plants grow taller when they receive more sunlight. That idea leads to a clear prediction: plants placed in a sunny spot should end up taller than matching plants placed in the shade. If the shaded plants grew just as tall, the hypothesis would be in trouble. Compare that with a claim such as, the plants grow because of an invisible force that no instrument could ever detect. No possible observation could ever count against that claim, so it cannot be tested, and scientists would not treat it as a scientific hypothesis at all, however interesting it might sound.
  • In the twentieth century, the philosopher Karl Popper turned this idea into a famous test, known as the criterion of falsifiability. According to Popper, a theory counts as scientific only if it is possible, at least in principle, to show that it is false. A classic example illustrates the imbalance between confirming an idea and refuting it, and it involves birds. No matter how many white swans you observe, you cannot prove the statement that all swans are white, because the next swan might be different, but a single well-documented black swan is enough to show that the statement is false. For this reason, Popper argued that scientific theories are never proved once and for all. Instead, they earn our confidence by surviving serious attempts to refute them, and they remain open to revision whenever new evidence appears, which is one of the great strengths of science.
  • Testing a hypothesis fairly requires careful experimental design, and the factor that a scientist deliberately changes is called the independent variable, while the factor that is measured to see whether it responds is called the dependent variable. In Lena's experiment, sunlight is the independent variable and plant height is the dependent variable. Everything else that could affect the result, such as the type of seed, the soil, the size of the pot and the amount of water, must be kept the same, and these are called controlled variables. Many experiments also include a control group, which does not receive the change being tested and serves as a baseline for comparison. Finally, a single trial demonstrates very little, because one plant may simply be unusual, so scientists repeat the test with many plants and check whether the difference holds up consistently across all of them.

Try it at home: Plan a fair test together, like which paper towel soaks up the most water, and name the variable you change, the one you measure and the ones you keep the same.

Questions and answers

Testing an Idea

  1. What is a hypothesis? A proposed explanation that can be checked (A hypothesis is checked against evidence.)
  2. What makes a hypothesis testable? Some observation could come out against it (A good hypothesis makes a definite prediction that could fail.)
  3. 📖 Who described the criterion of falsifiability? Karl Popper (The philosopher Karl Popper described it in the twentieth century.)
  4. According to Popper, when does a theory count as scientific? When it could in principle be shown false (Falsifiability means a theory could be shown false, at least in principle.)
  5. 🦢 Why can't seeing many white swans prove that all swans are white? The next swan might be different (One black swan would show the statement is false.)
  6. In Lena's experiment, what kind of variable is plant height? The dependent variable (Plant height is measured to see whether it responds to sunlight.)