Think, level 13
🧠 Mental Shortcuts and Biases
Why does your mind sometimes jump to the wrong answer?
- Why does your mind sometimes jump to the wrong answer? Much of everyday thinking relies on heuristics, which are mental shortcuts that let a person make quick judgments without working carefully through every detail of a problem. Shortcuts are usually helpful; without them, ordinary decisions, such as choosing a checkout line or estimating how long homework will take, would become slow and tiring, and you would have no time left for the things you want to do. In some situations, however, a shortcut leads people astray in a predictable direction, and that consistent, one-sided error is called a cognitive bias. In 1974 the psychologists Amos Tversky and Daniel Kahneman published an influential paper in the journal Science, titled “Judgment under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases.” The paper described three common heuristics, called representativeness, availability, and anchoring and adjustment, and it showed how each of them can produce systematic mistakes in judgment.
- Anchoring describes what happens when people estimate a number by starting from an initial value and then adjusting away from it. The difficulty is that the adjustment is usually too small, so the final estimate remains pulled toward the starting point, even when that starting point is irrelevant. Tversky and Kahneman reported that people's estimates were drawn toward starting numbers that had obviously been chosen at random. To see how this might work in practice, imagine two groups of students who are asked to guess the price of a used guitar in a music shop. The first group is asked beforehand whether it costs more or less than 900 dollars, while the second group is asked whether it costs more or less than 90 dollars. Anchoring predicts that the first group will tend to give noticeably higher guesses than the second. Yet both groups are looking at the very same guitar, and they know just the same things about it.
- The availability heuristic is the tendency to judge how common or how likely something is by how easily examples come to mind. Usually that strategy works reasonably well, because common things tend to be easy to remember. But vivid, recent or frequently reported events come to mind easily too, regardless of how often they actually occur. After a week of news stories about a lottery winner, for instance, winning may feel more likely than it really is, just because the story is fresh in your mind and easy to call up. Kahneman later received the 2002 Nobel Prize in economic sciences, in part for this work with Tversky. Knowing about biases does not make anyone immune to them, but a few deliberate habits can help: pause before an important judgment, ask where a starting number came from, look up the actual frequency instead of relying on memorable examples, and consider how someone with the opposite view would reason.
Try it at home: Before checking a price or a fact online together, each guess first, then talk about what number or story your guess was leaning on.
Questions and answers
Mental Shortcuts and Biases
- What is a heuristic? A mental shortcut for quick judgments (Heuristics let us judge quickly without working through every detail.)
- What is a cognitive bias? A consistent, one-sided error in judgment (A bias is a shortcut leading people astray in a predictable direction.)
- 📄 In what year did Tversky and Kahneman publish “Judgment under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases”? 1974 (The paper appeared in the journal Science in 1974.)
- Which of these is one of the three heuristics in their paper? Availability (The three were representativeness, availability, and anchoring and adjustment.)
- ⚓ In anchoring, what usually goes wrong with the adjustment away from the starting number? It is usually too small (The estimate stays pulled toward the starting point, even an irrelevant one.)
- Two groups guess a guitar's price after anchors of 900 dollars and 90 dollars. Which group does anchoring predict will guess higher? The 900-dollar group (The higher starting number pulls guesses upward.)