Think, level 6
⭕ All, Some and None
What do the words all, some and none really tell you?
- What do the words all, some and none really tell you? These three small words carry a lot of meaning in logic, which is the study of careful, clear thinking. All means every single one, with no exceptions, while some means at least one and maybe more, and none means not even one. Suppose your teacher tells the class that all the students in the room have a library card. If Maya is one of those students, then Maya must have a library card, and there is no way around it. A logical thinker calls that something that must be true.
- One helpful way to picture these words is to draw circles, with each circle holding one group of things. Put every dog inside one circle and every mammal inside a much bigger circle. All dogs are mammals, so the dog circle sits all the way inside the mammal circle. Now picture the sentence that some birds can swim, like ducks and penguins. The bird circle and the swimmer circle overlap a little, the way two coins look when you push them partly together. For the sentence that no fish are birds, the two circles do not touch at all. Drawings like these are called Venn diagrams.
- Circles can also show you what only might be true. Suppose some kids in the band play drums, and you know that Kai is in the band. Can you tell for sure whether Kai plays drums? You can't be sure, because he might play drums, but nothing in the facts says that he has to. You should be careful with the word all, too, because one case can knock down an all rule. That case is called a counterexample, which means an example that breaks the rule. If someone says that all birds can fly, a penguin is a counterexample, since a penguin is a bird that can't fly.
Try it at home: Take turns making an all rule about the kitchen, like "All our spoons are metal," then hunt together for a counterexample.
Questions and answers
All, Some and None
- In logic, what does the word all mean? Every single one
- In logic, what does the word none mean? Not even one
- ⚽ All the kids on the soccer team wear red socks. Leo is on the team. What must be true? Leo wears red socks (The rule covers every kid on the team, and Leo is on the team.)
- 🐾 All cats have whiskers. Rex has whiskers. What can you say about Rex? Rex might or might not be a cat (Dogs and other animals have whiskers too, so whiskers alone don't show Rex is a cat.)
- Someone says, "All birds can fly." Which one is a counterexample? A penguin (A penguin is a bird that can't fly, so it breaks the rule.)
- ♟️ No one in the chess club is older than 12. Ana is 14. What must be true? Ana is not in the chess club (Nobody in the club is over 12, and Ana is 14, so she can't be in it.)