Think, level 7
🍦 Cause or Just Together?
If two things happen together, does one cause the other?
- If two things happen together, does one cause the other? Not always, and learning to tell the difference is a very useful habit for any thinker. When two things tend to rise and fall together, scientists say that they are correlated. Here is a famous example: in many towns, ice cream sales climb during the very same summer months that sunburns climb. Does eating ice cream give people sunburns? Of course it doesn't, because both things simply happen more often in summer, when the days are long, hot and sunny. The two move together, but neither one causes the other.
- Summer weather is what careful thinkers call a third factor, which is a hidden cause that pushes two other things at the same time. Hot, sunny days make people want cold treats, and those same days also mean more hours spent outside in strong sunlight. Whenever you notice two things that seem to go together, stop and ask whether something else could be causing both of them. Here is another example to think about. Kids with bigger feet often read harder books, but big feet certainly don't help anyone read. Age is the third factor here, since older kids have both bigger feet and more years of reading practice.
- To find out what really causes something, scientists run a fair test, which means they change only one thing and keep everything else exactly the same. Suppose you want to know whether plant food helps beans grow taller. You could plant two groups of beans in the same kind of soil, give them the same amount of water, and set them in the same sunny window. Only one of the two groups gets plant food, and if that group grows taller, then the plant food, which is the one thing you changed, is the likely cause. Scientists call the thing you change on purpose the variable you are testing.
Try it at home: This week, spot a pair that goes together, like coats and cold noses, and talk about what really causes each one.
Questions and answers
Cause or Just Together?
- When two things tend to rise and fall together, scientists say they are… correlated
- 🍦 Ice cream sales and sunburns both go up in summer. What is the third factor? Hot, sunny weather (Summer weather pushes both things up at the same time.)
- Does eating ice cream cause sunburns? No, summer weather causes both (They go together because of summer, not because one causes the other.)
- What is a third factor? A hidden cause behind two things
- 👟 Kids with bigger feet often read harder books. What is the third factor? Age (Older kids have bigger feet and more reading practice, so age pushes both.)
- 🧪 In a fair test, how many things do you change on purpose? Just one (Changing only one thing lets you tell what caused the result.)