Think, level 8
⚖️ Weighing Evidence
How do you know which claims to believe?
- How do you know which claims to believe? A claim is a statement that someone says is true, such as an ad announcing that a new shoe will make you run faster. Evidence is the information that supports a claim or argues against it. Strong evidence usually comes from careful observations or measurements that other people can check for themselves, while weak evidence might be a rumor, a guess, or a single person's story. Before you accept any claim, ask what evidence backs it up. Then ask how good that evidence really is. A claim with no evidence at all is simply an idea that is still waiting to be tested.
- One story can be easy to remember, but by itself it is not much evidence. Imagine that your cousin says a new trick helped him learn his spelling words. Maybe the trick worked, or maybe that week's words just happened to be easy. Now imagine that researchers asked five hundred students to try the trick and compared their scores with five hundred students who studied the usual way. That is a much bigger sample, which is the group of people being studied. A larger sample that is chosen fairly is more trustworthy, because one unusual result can't change the overall picture very much. A sample made up only of kids who already loved the trick would not be fair.
- Our own minds can trick us, too. People tend to notice the evidence that agrees with what they already believe and to skip right past the evidence that doesn't, a habit that psychologists call confirmation bias. Suppose you believe your lucky socks help you win games. You will probably remember every win in those socks and quietly forget the losses. To fight confirmation bias, look on purpose for evidence that could show you are wrong, and count it as carefully as the evidence you like. Good thinkers also change their minds when new and better evidence comes along. Changing your mind is not the same as losing; it shows that you are following the evidence wherever it leads.
Try it at home: Pick a claim from a cereal box or a commercial, and talk together about what evidence would show whether it is true.
Questions and answers
Weighing Evidence
- What is a claim? A statement someone says is true
- 🔍 What makes evidence strong? Other people can check it (Careful observations and measurements that others can check make strong evidence.)
- Your cousin says a spelling trick worked for him. What kind of evidence is that? One person's story (It's one person's experience, and something else might explain it.)
- 👥 In a study, what is the sample? The group that gets studied
- Which one is the most trustworthy evidence? A large sample chosen fairly (In a big, fair sample, one unusual result can't change the overall picture much.)
- 🎮 A survey asks only kids who already love a game whether the game is fun. What is wrong with it? The sample isn't fair (Asking only fans leaves out everyone else, so the answer is lopsided.)