Skip to the main content
PeabodyMake a free story

🧩 Think, level 9

What the trails say and what they ask. Print it for the class, or put the same questions on the board with a live quiz.

Think, level 9

🕵️ Spotting Logical Fallacies

How can an argument sound convincing but still be faulty?

  • How can an argument sound convincing but still be faulty? An argument gives reasons, called premises, that are meant to support a conclusion. A logical fallacy is a mistake in reasoning that makes an argument weaker than it looks, even when it seems persuasive at first. One common fallacy is called ad hominem, a Latin phrase meaning against the person, because it attacks the person who is making an argument instead of the argument itself. Suppose Maya suggests that the school should put a recycling bin in the lunchroom, and Theo replies that Maya can't even keep her locker neat, so her idea must be silly. Theo has said nothing at all about whether a recycling bin would actually help, and whether Maya's locker is messy has nothing to do with whether her suggestion is a good one.
  • A second fallacy is the straw man, in which someone twists the other person's view or makes it far too simple, and then attacks that weaker version instead, a bit like knocking over a scarecrow rather than facing a real opponent. Imagine that Ava says she would like a little less homework on weekends, and Ben answers by asking whether she thinks students should never have to learn anything. Ava never said that. Ben has argued against an idea that is much easier to knock down than hers. A third fallacy is the false dilemma, which is also called either-or thinking, because it pretends there are only two choices when there are really more. Saying that either you join the soccer team or you don't care about staying active ignores the many other ways to stay active, such as swimming, biking or dancing.
  • A fourth fallacy is the slippery slope, which claims that one small step will lead, through a chain of further steps, to some extreme result, without showing that each step really has to follow. For example, someone might warn that if students are allowed to pick one song for the class party, next they will want to pick every lesson, and soon nobody will be in charge of the school. Each link in that chain is a guess. It is not a fact. To spot fallacies, slow down and ask yourself a few careful questions. Is the reply about the idea, or about the person? Is this really what the other side said? Are there truly only two possible choices? Does each step have to follow from the one before it? Asking these questions helps you judge an argument by the strength of its reasons.

Try it at home: Watch a few TV ads or listen to a friendly family debate together, and see if anyone can spot one of the four fallacies.

Questions and answers

Spotting Logical Fallacies

  1. What is a logical fallacy? A mistake in reasoning (A fallacy makes an argument weaker than it looks.)
  2. What does an ad hominem argument attack? The person making the argument (Ad hominem is Latin for against the person.)
  3. 🌾 In the straw man fallacy, what does someone attack? A twisted, weaker version of the other view (It is like knocking over a scarecrow instead of facing a real opponent.)
  4. What does a false dilemma pretend? That there are only two choices (A false dilemma, or either-or thinking, hides the other choices.)
  5. 🛝 Which fallacy claims that one small step will lead to an extreme result? Slippery slope (A slippery slope chains guesses together without showing each step must follow.)
  6. Lia says, “We should have longer recess.” Sam replies, “So you want no classes at all?” Which fallacy is this? Straw man (Sam twists Lia's idea into something she never said.)