Skip to the main content
PeabodyMake a free story

✏️ Write, level 13

What the trails say and what they ask. Print it for the class, or put the same questions on the board with a live quiz.

Write, level 13

🎤 Rhetorical Analysis

How can you explain why a speech works, even if you are not sure you agree with it?

  • How can you explain why a speech works, even if you are not sure you agree with it? A rhetorical analysis examines how a speaker or writer tries to accomplish a purpose with a particular audience, rather than judging whether the message itself is right. The first step is to map the rhetorical situation. It includes the text, the speaker who creates it, the audience who receives it, the purposes behind it and the setting, which means the time, the place and the circumstances in which it is delivered. Imagine a made-up speech: at a Monday morning school assembly, a ninth grader named Maya has three minutes to persuade her classmates to volunteer for a beach cleanup the following Saturday. Every choice she makes, from her first words to her last, can be understood by asking how it serves that specific purpose with that specific group of listeners, a question that guides the whole analysis.
  • Maya opens by holding up a jar filled with bottle caps and explaining that she gathered all of them in a single hour on the town beach. That opening is a deliberate choice, because a concrete object grabs the attention of a restless crowd far more quickly than a statistic would, and it quietly establishes that she has done the work herself. She then speaks in short sentences and uses the word "we" again and again, which positions her as a classmate rather than a lecturer. When she mentions that the cleanup will finish by noon and that free pizza will follow, she is anticipating the objections her listeners are likely to have, namely that the event will take up the whole weekend or feel like a chore. A careful analysis names each of these choices and explains precisely what each one is designed to accomplish for the people in the room.
  • A strong rhetorical analysis is organized around claims about strategy, not around a summary that simply retells the speech from beginning to end; a retelling shows what happened, but it does not show why it worked. A thesis for an analysis of Maya's speech might argue that she persuades a doubtful teenage crowd by replacing general warnings with evidence they can see and by presenting herself as an ordinary helper instead of an expert. Each body paragraph would then examine one strategy, quote or describe the moment where it appears and explain its effect on these particular listeners. The appeals you may already know, ethos, pathos and logos, are useful tools here. But naming an appeal is never enough, because the analysis must also explain how it works in that setting. Finally, you may judge how effective the choices are, but that judgment depends on the purpose and the listeners, not on whether you personally agree with the message.

Try it at home: Watch a short advertisement together. Name its audience and purpose, then point out one choice it makes, such as music or a slogan, and explain why it was chosen.

Questions and answers

Rhetorical Analysis

  1. What does a rhetorical analysis examine? How a speaker pursues a purpose with an audience (It studies how the choices serve the purpose, not whether the message is right.)
  2. Which list names the parts of the rhetorical situation? Text, speaker, audience, purpose, setting (These five parts describe who is speaking to whom, why, where and when.)
  3. In rhetorical analysis, what does the setting include? The time, place and circumstances (The setting is the moment in which the speech is delivered.)
  4. Why does Maya open with a jar of bottle caps? A concrete object grabs attention (A real object catches a restless audience faster than a number would.)
  5. What does Maya's repeated use of "we" accomplish? It presents her as a classmate (Saying "we" places her alongside the audience instead of above it.)
  6. Why does Maya mention finishing by noon and free pizza? To answer likely objections (She expects classmates to worry about losing the weekend or doing a chore.)