Write, level 6
🔬 Claim, Evidence, Reasoning
How do you back up your answer to a question?
- How do you back up your answer to a question? Scientists and writers often use a three-part plan called claim, evidence and reasoning. The claim comes first, and it is a sentence that answers the question. Suppose your class is asked which keeps ice frozen longer, a foam cup or a metal cup. Your claim might be that the foam cup keeps ice frozen longer. A good claim is short and clear, and it takes a side. It doesn't have to be fancy, but it does have to answer the exact question you were asked.
- Next comes the evidence, which is the facts that support your claim. Evidence might be numbers from a test you ran, something you saw for yourself, or a quote from a book or an article. In the cup test, your evidence could be that after one hour, the ice in the foam cup was still mostly solid, while most of the ice in the metal cup had melted. Evidence should be exact, so numbers and careful notes are stronger than words like a lot or pretty fast. If you can, give more than one piece of evidence.
- Last comes the reasoning, which explains why your evidence supports your claim. Reasoning connects the two parts, and it often uses a science idea to do it. For the cups, you might write that metal lets heat move through it easily, but foam slows heat down, so less heat from the warm room reached the ice in the foam cup. Reasoning often uses linking words like because and so. Without reasoning, a reader sees your facts but may not see why they matter. Together, the three parts make an answer that other people can trust.
Try it at home: Ask a question at home, like "Which room is warmest?" Make a claim together, gather evidence, and explain your reasoning.
Questions and answers
Claim, Evidence, Reasoning
- In claim, evidence and reasoning, what does the claim do? Answers the question
- 🧊 Which one is evidence? After an hour, the ice in the foam cup was still solid. (It is a fact someone saw and could check, not an opinion.)
- What does reasoning do? Connects the evidence to the claim (Reasoning explains why the evidence supports the claim.)
- 🔗 Which two linking words often show up in reasoning? because and so
- 🌿 The question is "Do plants need light to grow?" Which one is a claim? Plants need light to grow. (A claim is a sentence that answers the question and takes a side.)
- ⏱️ Which evidence is stronger? The ice melted in 40 minutes. (An exact number is stronger evidence than words like pretty fast.)