Write, level 9
🎯 A Strong Thesis
What turns a topic into an idea worth arguing about?
- What turns a topic into an idea worth arguing about? Every essay that argues a point needs a thesis, which is a sentence or two stating the main idea that the whole essay will support. Readers usually find the thesis near the end of the first paragraph, right after the writer has introduced the subject. A topic alone is not a thesis. The sentence "This essay is about the empty lot on Pine Street" only names a subject, and it gives the reader nothing to agree or disagree with. A thesis for an argument makes a claim, which is a statement that a thoughtful reader could question. The rest of the essay then supplies the evidence and reasons that support that claim.
- A strong thesis is arguable, which means that a sensible person could disagree with it. A plain fact, such as "The lot on Pine Street has been empty for three years," is not arguable, because anyone can check it, so there is nothing left to prove. A strong thesis is also specific, covering only what the essay will actually discuss. "Our town should improve the lot" is arguable, but it is too vague, since the reader cannot tell what the writer wants or why. Compare it with this version: "Our town should turn the empty lot on Pine Street into a community garden." Now the reader knows exactly which position the essay will defend, and the writer knows which evidence to gather.
- Many writers also let the thesis work as a roadmap, a short preview of the main reasons in the order the essay will present them. For example, a writer might say that the town should build the garden because it would give families fresh vegetables, create a safe place for neighbors to meet and serve as an outdoor science classroom. A reader can now predict that the body of the essay will have three main sections, one for each reason. Remember that a thesis can change while you write. If your evidence leads you somewhere new, revise the thesis so that it matches what the finished essay really argues, instead of forcing the essay to fit your first idea.
Try it at home: Pick a small question at home, like what to cook on Friday, and each write a one-sentence thesis with two reasons. Check together: is it arguable, and is it specific?
Questions and answers
A Strong Thesis
- What is a thesis? The main idea the whole essay supports (A thesis states the main point, and the rest of the essay backs it up.)
- Where do readers usually find the thesis? Near the end of the first paragraph (The thesis usually comes right after the writer introduces the subject.)
- Why is "This essay is about the empty lot" not a thesis? It only names a topic (Naming a subject gives the reader nothing to agree or disagree with.)
- What does it mean for a thesis to be arguable? A sensible person could disagree (An arguable claim leaves room for a reasonable reader to question it.)
- Which sentence is a fact rather than a thesis? The lot has been empty for three years (It can be checked, so there is nothing for an essay to prove.)
- Why is "Our town should improve the lot" a weak thesis? It is too vague (The reader cannot tell what the writer wants done or why.)